Scientists Confirm Century-Old Electron Bonding Theory

Quantum Bits QuBits Atomic Particle Physics
Researchers have discovered a stable single-electron covalent bond between two carbon atoms, confirming Linus Pauling’s 1931 theory. The study utilized oxidation of hexaphenylethane and analysis with X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy to reveal this new type of bonding, offering insights into future chemical research.

A breakthrough study has validated the existence of a stable single-electron covalent bond between two carbon atoms, supporting Linus Pauling’s early 20th-century theory and opening avenues for chemical research.

Covalent bonds, in which two atoms share a pair of electrons, form the foundation of most organic compounds. In 1931, the Nobel Laureate Linus Pauling suggested that covalent bonds made from just a single, unpaired electron could exist, but these single-electron bonds would likely be much weaker than a standard covalent bond involving a pair of electrons.

Since then, single-electron bonds have been observed, but never in carbon or hydrogen. The search for one-electron bonds shared between carbon atoms has stymied scientists.

Researcher Using X-Ray Diffractor To Study Sigma Bond
Using an X-ray diffractor to study the sigma bond. Credit: Yusuke Ishigaki

Experimental Breakthrough in Chemical Bonding

Now, a team of researchers from Hokkaido University has isolated a compound in which a single electron is shared between two carbon atoms in a remarkably stable covalent bond, known as a sigma bond. Their findings are published in the journal Nature.

“Elucidating the nature of single-electron sigma-bonds between two carbon atoms is essential to gain a deeper understanding of chemical-bonding theories and would provide further insights into chemical reactions,” explains Professor Yusuke Ishigaki of the Department of Chemistry at Hokkaido University, who co-authored the study.

Schematic of C–C Sigma Bond
Structure of the compound highlighting the C–C sigma bond (red). Credit: Takuya Shimajiri, et al. Nature. September 25, 2024

The single-electron bond was formed by subjecting a derivative of hexaphenylethane, which contains an extremely stretched-out paired-electron covalent bond between two carbon atoms, to an oxidation reaction in the presence of iodine. The reaction produced dark violet-colored crystals of an iodine salt.

The team used X-ray diffraction analysis to study the crystals and found that the carbon atoms in them were extremely close together, suggesting the presence of single-electron covalent bonds between carbon atoms. They were then able to confirm this using a form of chemical analysis called Raman spectroscopy.

Yusuke Ishigaki, Soki Kawaguchi, Takuya Shimajiri, and Takanori Suzuki
(from left) Yusuke Ishigaki, Soki Kawaguchi, Takuya Shimajiri, and Takanori Suzuki of the research team. (Photo provided by Yusuke Ishigaki). Credit: Laboratory of Organic Chemistry I, Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Hokkaido University

Implications and Future Research

“These results thus constitute the first piece of experimental evidence for a carbon-carbon single-electron covalent bond, which can be expected to pave the way for further developments of the chemistry of this scarcely-explored type of bonding,” Takuya Shimajiri, the lead author of the paper and now at the University of Tokyo, says.

Reference: “Direct evidence for a carbon–carbon one-electron σ-bond” by Takuya Shimajiri, Soki Kawaguchi, Takanori Suzuki and Yusuke Ishigaki, 25 September 2024, Nature.
DOI: 10.1038/s41586-024-07965-1